The day you stopped having to remember

Do you remember how many phone numbers you used to know by heart? Your best friends', your parents', maybe the pizza place's. And how many do you know today?
For most people the honest answer is: about one. Your own. Maybe.
That's no tragedy. It's a move. We shifted things from our heads into our phones, because the phone never forgets, is always with us and never gets tired. Who would argue with that?
A move nobody voted on
What's remarkable isn't that we outsourced, but how quietly it happened. There was no day when someone decided: "From today on I won't remember routes any more." There was just an evening when the navigation app was for the first time more certain than your own feeling, and then another evening when you didn't even try.
Researchers call this cognitive offloading. It means, quite generally, that we use tools so that we don't have to do mental work ourselves. A shopping list is cognitive offloading. So is a knot in a handkerchief. It's ancient and perfectly sensible.
It gets interesting when the tool becomes so good that we stop practicing the skill behind it.
What we know about finding things again
In 2011 Betsy Sparrow and colleagues published a much-cited study: people who expect information to be retrievable later are more likely to remember where it's than what it says. The brain is pragmatic. It saves where it can.
What matters is what does not follow from this. It doesn't follow that we're getting dumber. It only follows that we concentrate on what's needed, and today that's often: knowing where to look.
A second finding is more interesting, I think. In people who drive with navigation devices a lot, studies show on average a weaker spatial memory. Whether the navigation device is the cause, or whether people with a weaker sense of direction are more likely to reach for one, can't be said for sure from such data. Both are plausible, and the two directions probably reinforce each other.
What you no longer need, you don't unlearn overnight. You unlearn it in tenths, and each single step feels like nothing.
The moment you notice
You rarely notice it in the middle of everyday life. You notice it at the edges: the battery is dead and you're standing in a strange city. You're asked to estimate a bill and automatically reach for your phone, even though the numbers are small. You want to tell someone a poem, a joke, a recipe, and realize that all you know is where it is.
The feeling is rarely panic. It's more of a small, unfamiliar twinge. A "Hm. I used to be able to do that."
No sermon
We don't want to send anyone back to the time before the smartphone. The phone is a wonderful tool, and anyone who leaves their routes to the navigation app is doing nothing wrong.
But it's worth asking one question honestly: Which skills am I quietly giving up right now, and which of them would I actually have liked to keep?
Because the difference between "I don't need that" and "I can't do that any more" is bigger than it feels. The first state is a decision. The second is something that happened to us.
- You didn't forget that phone number because you no longer needed it. You forgot it because nobody ever asked you for it again.
- You can't find the way any more because you never walked it again without help.
- That bit of mental arithmetic is stuck because for years it's been a calculator job.
These aren't defects. They are muscles we use less. And with muscles, everyone knows what happens.
We're working on something that takes exactly this question seriously. Nothing strict, nothing preachy.